Are you convinced that enameled cast iron is right for you and your kitchen? Look no further. We&#;ve tested the best enameled cast iron skillets on the market to inform your decision. Each pan was rated and ranked based on design, performance, ease of cleaning, and durability until we found the perfect all-around skillets for every budget and kitchen.
Goto Gesywell to know more.
The non-reactive enamel material also holds up to the kinds of acidic foods that typically corrode cast iron, and the enamel surface is less prone to sticking. But cooking performance is almost the same. &#;Enameled cast iron skillets offer the benefits of standard cast iron skillets, like even heat distribution and heat retention, without the concerns about seasoning or reactivity,&#; says chef Taffy Elrod , an educator and cookbook author. (And if you use an induction stove , you don't have to worry; both raw and enameled cast iron are fully induction-compatible.)
While made from the same base material, enameled cast iron is another distinct category of cookware whose advantages can&#;t be denied. For one, enamel ensures easy cleanup without rusting. While raw cast iron requires a notable amount of attention and care, some enameled cast iron can even go in the dishwasher.
Cast iron pans are ubiquitous in American culinary tradition; most kitchens have at least one. As a material, cast iron is suitable for so much &#; grilling , browning , sautéing , or Dutch baby -ing &#; because of its unique ability to conduct heat and maintain temperature, not to mention the fact that it's nearly indestructible.
The cast iron Always Pan includes accessories most skillet don't &#; most importantly, a glass lid, along with silicone pot holders custom-shaped to the handles, and a beechwood spatula that nests conveniently into the main handle for storage. Our Place sells other supplementary accessories like a steamer basket and fry deck , too, making this one of the most versatile pieces of cast iron out there. We just wish it had a spout on the side. During testing, we struggled to pour cleanly. When we melted butter for the cornbread and had to pour it out, some dribbled down the side of the pan, which we had to wipe up to prevent it from burning in the oven, a possible safety concern.
We're big fans of Our Place's original ceramic Always Pan , and this version adds all the advantages of cast iron to the versatile design. This skillet does everything, from baking fluffy cornbread to rendering the fat on pork chops to braising short ribs in a slow oven. When we turned out the cornbread, we were shocked to see that the pan looked perfectly clean; there was no trace of crumbs or stuck-on pieces to be found. This skillet's above-average heat distribution was illustrated by the consistent and even sear we got on each and every pork chop. This pan also held on to heat quite well; while sauteing veggies, we didn't have to turn the fire above medium-low to get nice browning.
The thing we didn't like is the white enamel coating on the inside of this skillet. After a single use, it picked up some staining that couldn't be scrubbed away. Discoloration generally doesn't affect cooking performance with enameled cast iron, but the fact that the Crock-Pot skillet discolored so quickly gives us some worries about this pan's long-term survival.
The sides of this skillet are sloped and flared out, giving it a more rounded shape that can hold more liquid than a straight-sided pan. This is great for sauce-making, frying, or any recipe that's prone to slosh around in the pan. We were pleasantly surprised with the Crock-Pot pan's heat retention; our cornbread was cooked evenly, and we got a great crust on the meat. This skillet was impressively responsive to heat, heating up very quickly and proving easy to adjust. All in all, you can't go wrong at this price.
Enameled cast iron skillets can be expensive. If you&#;ve never used one and want to try it out for the first time without a big financial commitment, this Crock-Pot model is a great choice. It gets you high performance at a low price, and we'd recommend it whether you&#;re a first-timer or an experienced cast iron lover looking to add to your collection.
This inexpensive pan was very responsive the heat, and the sloped sides are great for sauces and frying.
The handle was our main problem in testing: It's pretty small and hard to grip comfortably. The helper handle is also a mere nub you have to pinch with your fingertips. Both handles are short and close to the pan, so they get very hot as well.
Despite the name, this skillet isn't much taller than most of the other on this list; the sharp internal angle and straight walls make it pan feel deeper &#; and prevent spatter. It feels solid, though not difficult to manipulate on a stovetop. The surface heated evenly and easily released the most delicate foods, like while crisping a piece of skin-on fish without sticking. Our cornbread was crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside, and it slid right out of the pan with no help and no residue or crumbs left behind.
Sometimes, splurging on a piece of cookware is the right thing to do. Whether it&#;s to guarantee a long life in your kitchen or to give as a gift, trusted brands like Staub with classic products like this skillet are the way to go. Staub makes our favorite Dutch oven , and we weren't very surprised that its skillet also turned up near the top of our list. The brand's products are known for their craftsmanship and durability, and we love the gorgeous, traditional style and array of colors available for Staub's enameled skillet.
We love how easily this skillet fits in the hand; it&#;s extremely comfortable to hold and pour from, and the additional helper handle made pulling the skillet from the oven much easier. However, that helper handle is definitely necessary; this skillet is the heaviest we tested, at almost 9 pounds before you add any food.
Given its stellar performance, KitchenAid's skillet was an obvious runner-up pick for our best overall. It knocked out every test and is almost as perfect as the Le Creuset above, while being larger and cheaper. It seared meat well, producing color and flavor, and our cornbread was flawless: perfectly baked and evenly golden brown on both top and bottom. We were extremely pleased with the lack of sticking; our cornbread turned out effortlessly, and this skillet released bacon from its surface with no prying or scraping required. Durability is a significant asset for an enameled cast iron skillet, and the KitchenAid model showed no signs of wear throughout our rigorous testing.
Le Creuset's skillet is on the heavy side for its size, which helps maintain even temperatures. You might need both hands to lift it, but the helper handle makes that easy, and the pour spouts on either side ensure you won't spill. We were pleased that the enamel showed no signs of wear, chipping, or stains, even after multiple uses. The only real gripe we had in testing was that the cornbread and fried egg stuck in some spots.
You'll find Le Creuset enameled cast iron all over our lists of favorites, including as one of our top-tested cookware sets , thanks to its powerful range of abilities (and its many eye-catching colorways). In our tests, we did everything from sweating onions to baking cornbread, and this pan easily accomplished every task. Its enamel coating was able to put a great crust on a piece of beef chuck, while creating a proper fond for a tasty pan sauce . It showed even heating across its surface, too, producing perfectly golden crepes in home testing.
Our Favorite
The Le Creuset Signature Enameled Cast Iron Skillet is gorgeous, with convenient pour spouts, the right amount of weight, and superior enamel coating. For a more budget choice that still gives all the benefits of enameled cast iron, we like the Crock-Pot Artisan Cast Iron Skillet.
Food & Wine / Nick de Jong
Our Enameled Cast Iron Skillet Tests
To find the best enameled cast iron skillets, we tested 23 models side by side. All of the pans had a diameter between 10 and 12 inches, and roughly the same height.
After completing our initial tests, we revealed the prices of the skillets to look at value for money. At the time of testing, the skillets ranged from $27 to $250, with an average of $96.
We also continued using the pans in our home kitchens as a long-term test. We incorporated them into daily cooking routines, searing, sautéeing, and generally making sure they held up over time. We reported back on any changes in cooking performance, and any signs of chipping, scratches, or warping.
Food & Wine / Maura Ruane
Factors to Consider
Weight
Comfort and maneuverability are significant factors when it comes to any kind of cookware, and that's especially true with cast iron. The high density that makes the material hold and transfer heat well also makes it very heavy. Consider how much weight you can comfortably lift out of the oven &#; including both skillet and contents &#; before you choose a size and shape. However, design can alleviate some of the inconvenience. A long and comfortably shaped handle helps balance out the weight of the pan, and most large cast iron skillets include a helper handle on the opposite side so you can use both hands. (Cast iron handles get hot, so make sure you have a pair of oven mitts on hand.)
Size
The difference between a 10- and a 12-inch skillet doesn't sound like much, but it's sort of like a medium versus a large pizza: The bigger one actually has almost 50 percent more area! How big your household is and what you plan to cook most often should guide your size choices, as bigger isn't always better: A 12-inch cast iron skillet weighs a lot more and takes up a lot more room than a 10-incher. Solo cooks or those just making a steak or two will be fine with a smaller diameter.
Maximum Temperature
Plain cast iron is one of the most heat-tolerant materials for pots and pans, able to handle the broiler, the grill, or even a campfire in most cases. But enameled cast iron can't always deal with the same temperatures, as the enamel coating itself can start to break down. You should always check your user manual as heat tolerance varies from skillet to skillet, but most enameled cast iron can withstand a maximum temperature of at least 500°F. That covers most oven and stove uses but not the broiler or grill. Some pans can go as high as 900°F, enough for even an outdoor pizza oven. The most important thing is to know the limit for your particular skillet, and stick to it.
Ease of Cleaning
&#;The nice thing about an enameled skillet is that it doesn&#;t need quite as much attention as a cast iron skillet. It does have to be treated with care, though. After cooking with it, wash it with warm, soapy water and dry it completely before putting it away,&#; says Elrod. &#;Some skillets have an exposed edge that is not enameled. That part of the skillet is still susceptible to rust and wear if it isn&#;t kept clean and dry, so be attentive to it.&#;
We recommend cleaning your pan immediately after cooking. Enameled cast iron is best cleaned before any food can dry and adhere to the surface to avoid staining and sticking. As with nonstick cookware, soap, water, and a gentle sponge should be all you need. Many types of enameled cast iron are even dishwasher-safe, as the enamel protects the delicate iron from rust and correction. And, as Chef Elrod notes, no seasoning is required with enameled cast iron.
Food & Wine / Frances Crouter
Enamel Color
A great thing about enameled cast iron is that the enamel coating can come in a rainbow of colors. Brands like Le Creuset and Staub have dozens of options, complete with collectible limited-edition and seasonal hues. Beyond aesthetics, though, the color of the enamel on the inside of the pan makes a difference in performance. Light or white enamel allows you to easily see everything in the pan and closely monitor the level of browning going on. The trade-off is that lighter-colored enamel can quickly stain or become discolored. Black enamel is immune to stains, but it can be hard to see how much browning food is taking on, leading to easier burning.
Why cook with an enameled cast iron skillet?
&#;I love cooking with cast iron,&#; says Elrod. &#;Enameled cast iron skillets offer the benefits of standard cast iron skillets, like even heat distribution and heat retention, without the effort of seasoning or concern of reactivity. For instance, I love baking pineapple upside-down cake in a cast iron skillet, but pineapple can react with cast iron and discolor the cake or interfere with the seasoning on the pan. In an enamel pan, I don&#;t have to worry about that. Enamel skillets are great for frying eggs with tomatoes, reducing wine-based sauces, baking cakes and quick breads, and sautéing acidic fruits and vegetables.
They are also a good alternative to nonstick skillets with no worries about wearing the finish off with everyday cooking.&#;
The enamel coating allows you more flexibility with less risk. Enameled cast iron doesn't react with acidic foods, so you don't have to worry about accidentally ruining the seasoning. It's also great if you're new to cast iron cooking and want the signature heat retention without all the upkeep.
How do you cook on an enameled cast iron skillet?
Enameled cast iron can be used for pretty much everything, even acidic foods and other ingredients you normally can't cook in raw cast iron. But it still absorbs and retains lots of energy as it heats up, so the most important thing is to let the pan pre-heat sufficiently.
&#;Cooking on an enameled skillet is different than cooking in a steel or aluminum skillet in that it&#;s best to use a lower, slower heat instead of a quick burst of high heat,&#; notes Elrod. &#;Give the skillet time to fully heat up over a lower heat, even if you want to cook something quickly. Cast iron&#;s strength lies in its ability to hold heat and radiate it evenly, so heating the pan fully on a lower heat before adding fat and cooking will give a better result and protect the integrity of the pan over time. This holds true for a standard cast iron skillet as well.&#;
The enamel coating usually isn't quite as completely nonstick as a traditional nonstick pan, but if things start to stick, give them a minute. Many notoriously sticky foods, like fish skin, will release from the enamel when they're ready, after much of their water has evaporated. Disaster often strikes if you try to flip before the food has had time to naturally pull away from the pan.
How do you care for an enameled cast iron skillet?
Be gentle with your enameled cast iron above everything else. In contrast to cleaning bare cast iron, you should avoid steel wool and other abrasive cleaners. If the enamel gets scratched, the iron beneath will start to rust and deteriorate. Elrod also says to avoid putting a hot pan in cold water, as drastic temperature changes can warp the iron or crack the enamel. The enamel used on cast iron is very durable, but as with nonstick pans, if the coating starts to chip or flake off, you should replace the pan.
What&#;s the difference between cast iron and enameled cast iron?
An enameled cast iron pan starts off as a regular cast iron pan, but it's then bonded to a layer of smooth enamel, much in the same way that a plain clay pot gets a coating of glaze. The enamel protects the iron from rust and corrosion and helps keep food from sticking to the surface of the pan. Enameled cast iron is more expensive than non-enameled, but it combines the heating properties of dense iron with the easy use and cleaning of a nonstick pan.
Do you need to season an enameled cast iron skillet?
Contact us to discuss your requirements of Enamel Coated Cast Iron Skillet. Our experienced sales team can help you identify the options that best suit your needs.
Thankfully, no! Iron is porous and prone to rusting when exposed to water or oxygen, so raw cast iron needs a seasoning layer to protect the bare metal. An enamel coating serves the same purpose, sealing off the iron and keeping corrosion at bay. Enamel doesn't need any special cleaning practices and is often dishwasher-safe, so it's a great choice for cast iron lovers who don't like the maintenance.
Food & Wine / Nicholas Reiter
Other Enameled Cast Iron Skillets We Tested
Strong Contenders
Great Jones 12-inch King Sear Skillet ($110 on Great Jones)
We don&#;t have many negative things to say about this attractive pan; it seared and browned nicely throughout the entire test. It's just is a bit heavy and didn't blow us away for being a bit pricier than average.
Bruntmor 12-inch Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Frying Pan ($45 on Amazon)
This pan seared meat successfully but had issues with more delicate foods, like eggs and cornbread, sticking to the surface. It's a good value, but there are better and still-inexpensive alternatives.
Staub Cast Iron 10-Inch Fry Pan ($210 on Amazon)
We love Staub with all our hearts, but the higher price for the smaller pan puts this just outside our best picks.
Made In 12-inch Enameled Cast Iron Skillet ($149 on Made In)
This is a fantastic pick, but it&#;s a bit heavy. If that doesn&#;t bother you, this one is a great buy.
Tramontina 12-inch Covered Skillet Enameled Cast Iron ($80 on Amazon)
We like this skillet&#;s tall, angled sides and handle, as well as its included lid, but the too-small pour spouts made it a little less appealing.
What Didn't Make the List
While many enameled cast iron skillets wowed us, others left us wanting more, including models from brands like Hamilton Beach, Cuisinart, Hearth & Hand, and more. On some, we didn't love design aspects like lack of pour spouts, too-short sides, or extreme weight. Others had problems with sticking, food not properly releasing, severe burning, or uneven heat distribution. Enameled cast iron cookware is generally a bit more expensive overall compared to raw cast iron, so for something to feel worth the investment, it really had to ace our tests, and some of the more expensive skillets we tested just didn't measure up.
Our Expertise
Christa Glennie has been a freelance writer and food editor for nearly 20 years. She is also the author of two cookbooks and specializes in food and drink trends, agriculture, the regional foodways of Western New York, and the restaurant business. For this piece, she used Food & Wine's tested insights and interviewed a chef instructor, recipe developer, and food writer.
To determine the best enameled cast iron skillets for your kitchen, we tested 23 popular options. We even asked the Allrecipes Allstars &#;our trusted team of expert home cooks&#;to help out. Our tests included baking cornbread to evaluate heat conductivity and the nonstick quality of the enameled surface, and pouring oil out of the skillet to assess the design of the pour spouts. We also seared a variety of proteins and sautéd additional foods to see how the pan performed. Lastly, we ranked the skillets in a number of critical categories:
An enameled cast iron skillet, however, has an added protective layer that eliminates the need for meticulous maintenance. The smooth enamel surface also makes it less prone to sticking and generally easier to clean, all while retaining the heating capabilities and durability of cast iron (plus, they&#;re very pretty).
There are a few pieces of cookware that we consider must-haves, and one of them is a cast iron skillet. Sturdily constructed with a reputation for superior heat retention, it&#;s a fairly versatile pan that can be used for high-heat searing and sautés, or lower heat simmers. But bare cast iron requires a little more upkeep than other cookware, like regular oiling to maintain its seasoning and prevent it from rusting.
One thing we didn&#;t love is that the two pour spouts are quite small, requiring you to be very careful when pouring anything from the pan. But with the overall performance, it&#;s nothing we can&#;t overlook.
We used this skillet to cook sausage and eggs, sear meats, and make grilled cheese sandwiches for testing. The heat stayed consistent without any adjustments to the flame, a testament to the pan&#;s ability to retain heat. Searing meat was quite easy, and the lid allowed us to finish cooking our proteins to temperature without having to transfer them to the oven. The cornbread was baked evenly and came out with zero sticking.
This 12-inch skillet from Tramontina provides a generous cooking surface, and features a helper handle and two pour spouts. A heavy cast iron lid keeps moisture and heat trapped to aid in cooking or to keep contents warm. It&#;s compatible with just about every cooktop and is oven safe up to 450°F.
To test this skillet, we asked one of the Allrecipes Allstars to use it in her own kitchen. Allstar Terri McHugh appreciated the overall design and size of the skillet, calling it the "perfect cast iron skillet for the everyday cook." In tests, the pan heated evenly, cooked food easily released without any stickiness, and cleanup was a breeze.
With six stylish colors to choose from and a versatile, lightweight design, this beautifully designed cast iron skillet from Caraway is definitely worth adding to your kitchen collection (or gifting to that special home cook in your life). The 10.5-inch size is ideal for a wide range of recipes without being too bulky for storage, although we wouldn't blame you if you left it out on the stove to display while not in use. It's also oven safe up to 500°F and compatible with all cooktops. Even better, Caraway offers a lifetime warranty on the pan since it's designed to last a lifetime with proper care.
We tested this with a variety of cooking methods, from making rice pilaf to stir-frying vegetables to searing meat. Searing with this pan gave a gorgeous, even crust, showing off the excellent heat distribution of this skillet. Cornbread also baked evenly and released without any sticking. The one fault is that it lacks pour sprouts, which means there&#;s more of a chance of making a mess when pouring off juices or oil. Regardless, it&#;s a beautiful piece and also has additional accessories you can buy&#;like a steamer basket or tagine lid &#;that really expands the range of what this pan can do.
Our Place&#;s contemporary style and gorgeous colorways will have you oohing over this pan&#;s aesthetics alone. Aside from being really ridiculously good looking, this 10.5-inch pan comes with a glass lid, silicone covers for its handles, and a wooden spatula&#;everything you need to start using it. The pan is oven safe to 425°F with the lid and 500°F without, and should be hand washed.
This skillet evenly sautéd mirepoix , seared a variety of meats, and made perfect cornbread. The latter baked evenly and popped right out of the pan with zero sticking, which we loved. There was also a nice sear on chicken breasts and pork chops, noting that the higher walls of the pan kept grease fairly contained. One downside is that the light interior is susceptible to staining, but if you don&#;t mind the &#;gently worn&#; look, we think this pan delivered a great performance, especially considering its low price.
You don&#;t need to spend a ton for a good enameled cast iron skillet&#;this model from Crock-Pot does the job nicely at an easy price point. We tested the 10-inch diameter pan, but it also comes in an 8-inch and 12-inch version and a variety of color options. It features a light interior so you can easily monitor your fond in progress, and two spouts for effortless pouring.
Grain of Salt: Not as balanced as others; interior tends to stain
It was incredibly easy to fry eggs, caramelize onions , sear beef, and bake cornbread in the skillet. Crepes came out evenly cooked with no hot spots detected, showing off its even heating capabilities. The enamel coating is mostly nonstick, but there was a little sticking when it came to making eggs and cornbread. While we did achieve a great sear on beef chuck, the sides of this pan seemed a little shallow, which resulted in some spattering. But overall, this is an excellent investment that will stand up well in your kitchen and likely last the test of time with proper care.
Le Creuset is perhaps the benchmark for enameled cast iron cookware, with a long-held reputation for quality goods that are often handed down through generations. This skillet measures 10.25 inches in diameter but also comes in 9-inch and 11.75-inch options. Available in many stylish colors, it&#;s a great-looking piece that can also act as serveware. It&#;s oven safe to 500°F and comes with a limited lifetime warranty against defects in materials and workmanship.
It delivered even, consistent heating and an excellent sear during tests. We were able to make flawless cornbread that released effortlessly&#;no utensils required. The long handle was very comfortable when maneuvering the pan with an oven mitt, while the helper handle proved its worth when moving the pan and using its pour spouts. The price is higher than what you&#;d pay for a regular cast iron pan, but the enamel finish adds more durability and style, making it a vessel that goes easily from stove to table.
KitchenAid&#;s 12-inch enameled cast iron pan is a fantastic combination of performance, quality, and overall value. Its generous size makes it ideal for cooking up large portions, providing maximum surface area for searing and sautéing. The exterior of the pan comes in several colorways, with a matte black interior that camouflages any evidence of wear and tear. Compatible with induction, it&#;s also oven safe up to 500°F, so you can finish items in the oven if needed.
Our Takeaway
For the best combination of performance, value, and style, we like the KitchenAid Enameled Cast Iron Frying Pan. It&#;s got a generous cooking surface and an impressively nonstick surface that we can&#;t get enough of. For a less expensive option, we picked the Crock-Pot Artisan Cast Iron Skillet which is slightly smaller, but has higher walls that contain splatter. We can&#;t ask for a better overall performance at its super approachable price.
How to Pick the Right Enameled Cast Iron Skillet
Design
Most enameled cast iron skillets have a similar general design&#;wide cooking surface, medium-high sides, and a generously sized handle to bear its heft. However, slight variations can make all the difference when it comes to how the pan performs. You&#;ll want to pick a size appropriate for your cooking needs; if you need to sear a lot of protein at once, a larger skillet will ensure your meats won&#;t be too crowded. Since these pans tend to be heavy, a helper handle will assist greatly in transporting them on or off the stove or in and out of the oven. Lastly, pour spouts are an important feature for transferring liquids like oil or pan juices from your skillet to another vessel.
Color
While the exterior color of your enameled cast iron skillet can be a factor in your selection, in this instance, we&#;re talking about the color of the interior of your skillet. Some might prefer a light interior, which makes it easier to monitor the development of fond. The drawback to a light interior is that it is prone to staining. Dark interiors are equally as nonstick and efficient as lighter ones, but can also hide signs of wear better.
Care and Storage
One of the benefits of enameled cast iron is that it is much easier to care for than bare cast iron&#;since it does not require the additional steps to maintain its seasoning. Most enameled cast iron is easy to clean by hand with mild dish soap and a non-abrasive scrubber. To remove stains on light-colored enamel, you may want to use some baking soda or Bar Keeper&#;s Friend with a bit of elbow grease. Since these skillets tend to be bulky and heavy, be sure you have enough room to store your chosen size.
The Leftovers: Other Enameled Cast Iron Skillets We Tested
Allrecipes / Nicholas Reiter
Common Questions
How long does enameled cast iron last?
Most of (if not all) of the selections we&#;ve included are made to last a lifetime with proper care. While the enamel is very durable, it may be prone to cracking if dropped or struck and can also be subject to crazing&#;little cracks under the enamel&#;if subjected to thermal shock. Always let enameled cast iron cool completely before submerging it in water, avoid using harsh abrasives, and be careful when handling your cookware to keep your enamel intact. If your enamel does start to chip or crack, it may be time for a new pan.
Is there anything you shouldn&#;t cook on enameled cast iron?
Not really! The beauty of enamel is that it&#;s nonreactive, meaning it can handle acidic ingredients like tomatoes and vinegar without issue, unlike bare cast iron. With an enameled cast iron skillet, you can stir-fry vegetables, sear meats, make gooey mac n' cheese, create tasty omelets, and even bake tasty desserts.
Do you need to season an enameled cast iron skillet?
No. The enameled finish essentially acts as seasoning to protect the bare cast iron underneath, so there&#;s no need to preseason or maintain its finish aside from general cleaning. This is a great option for people who like cast iron cooking without the additional hassle.
Why Take Our Word for It?
Bernadette Machard de Gramont is an Los Angeles-based writer who specializes in global food and wine content. After a 2-year stint at the Williams-Sonoma Headquarters in San Francisco, she now researches and tests a variety of cookware, bakeware, wine tools, and other home and kitchen goods and interviews field experts for their insight.